Don't overcook a golden goose - Is keeping money in your GESB West State costing you big future tax savings? - Empire Financial Group
back-arrow

Back

Don’t overcook a golden goose – Is keeping money in your GESB West State costing you big future tax savings?

Financial Advisors Perth | Empire Financial Group

Raymond Pecotic

MD Empire Financial Group

Raymond is the founder and Managing Director of Empire Financial Group, and a Responsible Manager of our Australian Financial Services Licence, EFG Advice Australia.

(This article was first published in The West Australian, YourMoney, on 10 August 2026)

From time to time, I tell Western Australian government employees something that can sound almost sacrilegious.

You should roll your money out of GESB West State.

There, I have said it.

But not for the reasons some may think.

There is no shortage of advisers unaware of the tremendous benefits GESB West State members can enjoy, who unwittingly roll their clients’ funds into portfolios they manage. Their advice and motivations need to be seriously challenged.

However, there can be circumstances where keeping your money in West State can cost you significant future tax savings and stifle your ability to use its unique features to boost your retirement benefits.

Remember, government employee members of GESB West State are not restricted to the $32,500 annual concessional contribution cap that the rest of us mere mortals are.

Instead, they have the unique opportunity to make substantial salary sacrificed contributions in any one year up to their lifetime untaxed plan cap, which from 1 July 2026 increased to $1.935m.

But here is the catch.

Investment earnings inside the West State environment can also consume that valuable lifetime capacity.

This becomes particularly relevant for those with significant balances.

Consider a government employee with $1 million in West State who earns an 8% investment return in a year.

In this case, that $80,000 investment earning effectively consumes part of the member’s remaining lifetime capacity and negates that same $80,000 in future potential tax deductible contributions.

Now, let’s say this government employee is earning $200,000 a year, with a spouse earning $150,000, and their mortgage is almost paid off, their children have left home, and have  substantial surplus cash flow.

In ordinary circumstances, a $200,000 income earner would have $24,000 of their annual contribution cap taken up with standard employer contributions, allowing only $8,500 to be salary sacrificed and claimed as a deduction.

However, in this case, the proposal could be to salary sacrifice $155,000.  This brings their income down to $45,000, at which point the differences in tax rates make it less attractive to salary sacrifice further.

In very basic terms, this would reduce this person’s annual income tax bill from $59,870 to only $4,020. When we factor in the 15% tax on contributions in the fund, there would be an annual net tax saving of $32,600.

That’s a real saving, and well worth pursuing.

But it also demonstrates the problem.

A salary sacrifice of $155,000 plus $24,000 in standard employer contributions would produce total annual contributions of roughly $179,000.

Starting with $1 million, adding $179,000 a year and assuming an 8 per cent annual investment return, the super balance would rise to about $1.259 million after year one, $1.539 million after year two, $1.841 million after year three and more than $2.16 million after year four. Assuming indexation at circa 3% per annum on the lifetime cap and salary sacrifice, it would mean the ability to contribute to the fund would be exhausted in about four years.

But it also means that over $480,000 of precious lifetime cap and future tax deductions was used up by investment growth.

And that is the strategic question.

The solution could be preserve West State as the vehicle for high value salary sacrifice contributions, but move the balance elsewhere to quarantine growth, thus stretching out the ability to make future salary sacrifice.

Suppose $999,000 were moved out to another regular super fund, leaving $1,000 in West State.

At a 15 per cent tax rate, the immediate tax cost on that transfer would be about $150,000.

At first glance, that looks like a significant price to pay.

But it is also the wrong question to ask in isolation.

Firstly, the tax would need to be paid at some point in the future anyway, so that is not the cost. The cost is the value of the investment earnings that $150,000 would be earning over the relevant time frame.

What needs to be explored is whether the value of preserving additional years of large tax deductible contributions is greater than the investment growth lost on the tax paid today.

In the case discussed above, by moving funds into an ordinary super fund, having earnings generated there, and contributing to West State before regularly rolling funds out to minimise earnings in the fund, the ability to contribute to GESB West State at the significant levels described above stretches out to almost 7 years.

It means we can get an additional $530,000 in tax deductible, salary sacrificed contributions into West State for an additional $240,000 in tax savings.

Meanwhile, in that same period, the investment earnings on the $150,000 in tax would have only totalled $135,000.

The numbers tell a compelling story.

The extraordinary feature of GESB West State contribution opportunity has a finite lifetime limit, and investment growth can reduce it further.

For people approaching retirement with large balances, the strategy may involve separating those two factors – use West State for what makes it valuable, while considering whether existing capital should be invested elsewhere.

That is a much more nuanced proposition than simply asking whether keeping money in West State is a “good” or “bad” idea.

And with potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars of future tax deductions at stake, it is a question worth asking a suitably experienced adviser to assist in calculating.

Raymond Pecotic is the Managing Director of Empire Financial Group

You May Also Read

Red flags for those shifting rental gear

Red flags for those shifting rental gear

(This article was first published in The West Australian, YourMoney, on 2 November 2026) If you listen carefully, you might just hear the screeching of the handbrake being pulled on the Australian residential property investment market. The changes announced at the...

read more

Sign up to our newsletter to receive our latest and best articles straight to your inbox.